← Back to Signals
Dependency matrix of four quantum architectures on ytterbium, helium-3, niobium and silicon-28, with evidence ratings

Signals

Dependency signalMap updated on November 7, 2026 · Chinese deadline checked on November 6, 2026

What does each quantum architecture depend on? A map of critical-material dependencies

This map crosses four quantum architecture families with four critical materials. Each cell carries an evidence rating: A1 official text, B2 cross-checked sources, C3 single source. Photonics is not assessed in this edition due to insufficient sources.

CriticalTo watch or changingNo dependency identified
ArchitectureYtterbiumHelium-3NiobiumSilicon-28
Superconducting (IBM, Rigetti, IQM, OQC, Fujitsu, Alice & Bob, D-Wave)No dependency identified in our sourcesCritical (B2): dilution refrigerators, limited supplyTo watch (B2): main circuit materialNo dependency identified
Trapped ions (IonQ, Quantinuum)Declining (B2): barium in development at IonQ, adopted by Quantinuum (Helios, 2025)No dependency identifiedNo dependency identifiedNo dependency identified
Neutral atoms (Atom Computing, Pasqal, QuEra, Infleqtion)Critical for 1 player out of 4 (B2): Atom Computing uses ytterbium-171, the others rubidium or cesiumNo dependency identifiedNo dependency identifiedNo dependency identified
Silicon spin (Quobly, Diraq, Intel)No dependency identifiedSingle source (C3): depends on operating temperatureNo dependency identifiedEmerging diversification (B2): ASP Isotopes, Soitec, STMicroelectronics, Quobly
PhotonicsNot assessed in this edition, insufficient sources

Helium-3 for silicon: Quobly's sources (press releases and a conference abstract co-authored by its staff) describe on its development platform a helium-3 cooler for the 500 mK stage, and operation at 1 K with helium-4. This holds for that player only.

Rubidium, outside the map: according to the USGS (February 2026), no rubidium mine production was reported worldwide in 2025, and refining is estimated to take place in China and Germany from stockpiles. Rubidium is not in Annex II of the EU Critical Raw Materials Act, which lists 34 materials.

11/10days until the Chinese suspension of the controls in announcement No. 57 (including ytterbium) ends, scheduled for November 10, 2026.

China's deadline, checked on November 6, 2026: MOFCOM and Customs announcement No. 70 of 2025 suspends announcements No. 55, 56, 57, 58, 61 and 62 until November 10, 2026. Ytterbium is in announcement No. 57 (code 1C913). The US-China truce was extended to January 10, 2027 according to a ministry statement of September 28, 2026, which does not name rare earths: no published text extends this suspension so far. The general dual-use licensing regime still applies.

Clarifications: the suspension covers the controls in announcement No. 57, which does not mean ytterbium is free of any licence. Ratings reflect the evidence level of each cell, not the severity of the risk. To be rechecked on the ministry's website on the day of the deadline. Not a rating of companies and not investment advice.

Sources: MOFCOM and Customs announcement No. 70 of 2025 ; announcement No. 57 as reproduced by Xinhua ; Ministry of Commerce statement of 09/28/2026 ; USGS, rubidium 2026

See also

Five Materials, One Fragility

Analysis note, material dependencies.

See also

Quantum: The Invisible Race

Thematic report, 22 pages.