Quantum: The Invisible Race
Material, technological and legal dependencies in the race for quantum sovereignty.
Public debate on quantum computing focuses almost entirely on its most visible indicators: qubit counts, error-correction performance and announcements of "quantum supremacy". This report takes a different point of view. The competition is also played out upstream, in access to a few materials whose production or processing is highly concentrated. It is played out downstream, in contractual access to a third party's computing power for players without infrastructure of their own.
These two forms of dependency are subject to scattered national, European and contractual rules, but to no unified international regime comparable to those that govern certain other strategic resources. The United States and China have developed export control instruments and extraterritorial mechanisms that pursue comparable aims without being legally identical. The European Union, for its part, combines several registers: blocking statute, response to economic coercion, data protection, dual-use export controls and national investment screening.
The CRMA gap, an opportunity for normative pre-emption in Europe. Of the 13 materials tracked by the Observatory, four are named on the Critical Raw Materials Act list (gallium, niobium, strontium, tantalum), six fall under a generic sub-category of the regulation, and three are absent (indium, rubidium, electronic-grade synthetic diamond). This gap documents a window for regulatory action by the Union rather than a mere omission.
A legal balance of power across three regimes. The report details the American and Chinese export control regimes, distinct from their respective sanctions regimes (IEEPA/OFAC on the American side, the 2021 Anti-Foreign Sanctions Law on the Chinese side), and sets them against European instruments: blocking statute, anti-coercion instrument, GDPR and the export regime specific to quantum.
Solutions by nature, not a single answer. The report concludes with complementary levers: industrial (supplier diversification, strategic reserves, allied refining capacity), regulatory (a quantum technical annex to the CRMA, a European register of critical dependencies), diplomatic (bilateral supply agreements) and capital-related (dedicated financing to secure the value chain).