← Back to Data

Data · Physical Chain Pillar

Value Chain Criticality Index by Material

The Value Chain Criticality Index, or ICV, is a proprietary tool developed by Observatoire Quantique. It assigns each material a score between 0 and 100. The higher the score, the greater the estimated level of criticality. To preserve the distinctive value of the tool, its calculation method, criteria, weightings, and aggregation rules are not made public. The results allow materials to be compared within the panel studied. They serve as indicators to support analysis and should not be interpreted as absolute scientific measurements.

The panel comprises thirteen materials required by at least one quantum architecture currently under development or in operation. The general criteria, sources used, scores obtained, and methodological limitations are documented.

Value Chain Criticality (ICV) by Material
Criticality score, 0-100, higher = more critical.
Rare earths / ytterbium
96.9
critical
Helium-3
94.3
critical
Gallium
93.8
critical
Niobium
85.6
critical
Indium
77.6
critical
Tantalum
77.6
critical
Strontium
76.8
critical
Rubidium
66.2
to monitor
Silicon-28
63.6
to monitor
Lithium niobate
60.6
to monitor
Very high-purity aluminum
60.5
to monitor
Synthetic diamond (NV)
57.9
to monitor
Germanium-70 (depleted isotope)
55.6
to monitor
Methodological notes.

The 75-point threshold separating the "To monitor" and "Critical" levels is provisional. It may evolve as the panel and available data are further developed.

The panel was expanded to thirteen materials on 19 July 2026 with the addition of strontium, rubidium, germanium-70, gallium, and indium. The inclusion of gallium and indium notably brings this mapping closer to the European list of critical raw materials.

The Quantum Delta NL study, Critical Raw Materials for Quantum Technologies, published on 27 November 2023, also lists cesium, titanium, barium, phosphorus, tungsten, arsenic, copper, nickel, and antimony. These materials are not yet assessed under our method and therefore do not appear in the current ranking.
See also

Geographic concentration of capacities

Who produces, refines, or processes these materials, country by country.

See also

Exposure × preparedness, by country

Cross-analysis across seven representative countries (IEM×IPR).

See also

Vulnerability of market participants (IVA)

Complete mapping, company by company.

See also

Post-quantum migration timelines

Cryptographic transition deadlines, by jurisdiction.